With little change in gown cleaning services over the past 50 years, Richard Kinsman, CO2Nexus, argues that cleanroom garment users in the US would benefit from a more innovative approach to laundering
The future of innovative manufacturing must take into account the environmental footprint of operations
US cleanroom garment laundering service models have not changed in decades to the detriment of innovators in pharmaceuticals, biotechnology and electronics. The cleanroom service model used in the US has been employed for almost 50 years with little change in technology or key service providers. As a result, cleanroom manufacturers remain tied to inflexible contracts and are increasingly exposed to increasing regulatory and environmental costs.
The industry would benefit from innovative approaches to processing cleanroom garments that offer cost, performance and environmental advantages. US cleanroom laundry facilities and operations maintain a similar design with a large footprint and inefficient operations. AMD’s Patent Number 61228931 outlines the basic cleaning methodology using a ‘pass-through’ commercial washer to control garment exposure to contaminants. The washers use stainless steel baskets with ultra-pure water, which requires an energy-intensive process to produce. The dryers must open to the cleanroom and be constructed to eliminate potential contamination from the surrounding environment.
Cleanroom service providers must verify the cleanliness of the garments by ‘measuring the number and sizes of particulates present within the laundered textiles using a Helmke Drum and aerosol particle counter’.
In many cases, legacy service providers have fully depreciated the infrastructure and equipment in service centres
Most laundering and processing is conducted off-site, which requires transport of customer garments over significant distances to regional hubs. Providers service cleanroom manufacturers through major regional market hubs where they process multiple clients’ garments. Major regional market hubs are fairly easy to identify, as they are created by geographical grouping of customers that can be served from centralised, multi-customer consolidated operations.
In many cases, legacy service providers have fully depreciated the infrastructure and equipment in service centres leaving little interest in investing in innovative technologies or revamping operations.
Most consolidated facilities in the US are located in or close to the following regional market hubs:
Smaller regional hubs exist in Seattle, Denver, Minneapolis and Boston. Similar service models are deployed from these locations.
Providers service cleanroom manufacturers through major regional market hubs where they process multiple clients’ garments
Current cleanroom contracts diminish end user flexibility. Over the past 20 years, many end users have been pushed into de facto mandatory leasing of cleanroom garments through long-term contracts. In many situations a garment owner cannot have them cleaned by principal service providers unless they purchase or lease directly from that same provider. Service providers then group these contracts geographically, as described above, to consolidate multiple client orders to achieve economies of scale.
This creates a challenge in the supply chain for end users; they must purchase or lease additional garments to offset long distance delivery schedules and delays. This move has locked end users into large, long-term contracts, further diminishing incentives to invest in new cleanroom garment processing technologies and services. Given how essential these garments are to manufacturing, end users are left with little or no leverage to negotiate.
Some cleanroom customers in the US express frustration with existing cleanroom garment processing services, because:
Existing cleanroom garment laundering technology relies heavily on clean water sources and is vulnerable to water price, quality and scarcity
Under the status quo, cleanroom sectors in the US remain exposed to regulatory and environmental risks from energy- and water-intensive processes. Existing cleanroom garment laundering technology relies heavily on clean water sources and is vulnerable to water price, quality and scarcity; water regulations are pending across the US. Inevitably these risks will drive up operating costs, which will be passed to end-users.
Furthermore, supply chain transparency increasingly exposes end users to their service provider’s ‘footprint’. Acknowledging the drive towards more transparency, the International Organisation of Standardisation (ISO) published the principles and guidelines of tracking and managing an organisation’s water footprint.
Existing US cleanroom laundering services face the following environmental constraints:
Rising capital and operating costs due to energy and water consumption to:
Deplete valuable water resources from local communities to:
New cleanroom operations in the US will face substantial costs to secure fresh water and from siting, permitting, building and managing the infrastructure needed to use and treat water. Meanwhile, the use of water-based washing processes degrades the garment integrity, further increasing costs to service providers and ultimately to end-users.
Cleanroom manufacturing is advancing rapidly while the services that support it lag behind
In summary, the cleanroom laundry services industry needs to innovate. As cleanroom manufacturing evolves to produce more advanced products, including more sophisticated biotechnology and nanotechnology products, cleanroom laundry services will need to adapt as well. Cleanroom manufacturing is advancing rapidly while the services that support it lag behind.
Likewise, the future of innovative manufacturing must take into account the environmental footprint of operations; social and regulatory pressures are pushing industries toward this now. To date, innovative cleanroom garment laundering solutions have not been deployed, despite their current availability in the market.
CO2-based cleanroom garment laundry is commercially available today and can deliver up to 60% energy savings, eliminate up to 96% of water usage and improve garment life. Tersus Cleanroom Solutions, offered by CO2Nexus, is a proven technology that disrupts the existing legacy protocols for cleanroom laundering. It greatly reduces the use of energy and virtually eliminates the need for processing, heating, storing or disposing of water.
Using the natural cleaning abilities of liquefied CO2 in a completely contained environment, such a system does not need dryers, boilers or deionised water systems. The footprint of cleanroom laundry shrinks and garments are never exposed to dry or wet heat, resulting in extended garment life cycles.